Content note: this post discusses a murder and the disposal of a body. We’ve kept the detail minimal.

If you grew up in India in the nineties, “tandoor” stopped meaning only bread for a while. This is the case that did that, and it’s also an early example of something we’ve talked about a lot on this blog: a crime that was solved not by brilliant detective work but by one person paying attention.

2 July 1995, Connaught Place

Late at night, a Delhi Police constable on patrol near the Bagiya restaurant at the Ashok Yatri Niwas hotel noticed thick smoke and flames from the kitchen area. When he and a colleague investigated, they found the restaurant manager, Keshav Kumar, feeding something into the tandoor. He said they were burning old Congress party banners.

They weren’t.

Who she was

Naina Sahni was 29, a Delhi Youth Congress worker and a trained pilot, married to Sushil Sharma, the president of the Delhi Youth Congress and a man with real political connections. The marriage was, by every account that came out later, controlling and violent. Sharma suspected her of an affair with a party colleague.

On the night of 2 July, he came home, found her on the phone, and shot her with his licensed revolver. Then he drove her body to the restaurant he part-owned, and he and the manager tried to make it disappear.

The chase

Sharma fled Delhi that night. For the next week he moved through Jaipur, Mumbai, Chennai and Bangalore while the story dominated every front page. He eventually surrendered in Bangalore on 10 July. Keshav Kumar was arrested at the scene.

The trial, and the death sentence that wasn’t

In 2003 a Delhi sessions court convicted Sharma and sentenced him to death, calling the case “rarest of rare.” The Delhi High Court upheld that in 2007. Keshav Kumar got seven years for helping destroy evidence.

Then, in 2013, the Supreme Court commuted Sharma’s death sentence to life. The reasoning: this was a crime driven by a personal relationship, not a threat to society, and he had no prior record. It was a controversial judgement at the time and it still is.

In December 2018, after 23 years in jail, the Delhi High Court ordered his release, ruling that he’d served more than the maximum effectively allowed and that the sentence review board had been unfair in refusing him. He walked out of Tihar. He’s reportedly been living quietly since.

Why it mattered

Three reasons. It was the first Indian case where DNA testing was used to identify a victim’s remains, which set a precedent. It happened to a politically connected man and he was still convicted, which in 1995 was not a given. And it was the case that taught Indian newspapers how to cover a crime as a daily serial, for better and worse.

It’s also a reminder of the pattern we keep finding, from Burari to Aarushi: the official story and the lived one are rarely the same. Naina’s family said for years that the police had been called about violence before. Nobody acted until the smoke.

Do you think the Supreme Court was right to commute the sentence? Genuinely curious, because I go back and forth.


Discover more from Lore in Noir

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Podcast also available on PocketCasts, SoundCloud, Spotify, Google Podcasts, Apple Podcasts, and RSS.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Discover more from Lore in Noir

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading