Content note: this post discusses the murder of a young woman. We’ve kept out graphic detail.

Some cases are hard because there are no clues. This one is hard because there are too many people with a reason to lie. Let’s lay it out.

Who’s who

Indrani Mukerjea was, in 2015, one of Mumbai’s best-known media executives, co-founder of INX Media with her husband Peter Mukerjea, a former Star India CEO. She had introduced Sheena Bora, 24, to Mumbai society as her younger sister. Sheena was actually her daughter from an earlier relationship in Guwahati, as was Sheena’s brother Mikhail.

Sheena was also in a relationship with Rahul Mukerjea, Peter’s son from his first marriage. Which made her, depending on how you count, her boyfriend’s step-aunt. The family tree alone would fill a post.

April 2012: Sheena vanishes

On 24 April 2012, Sheena was last seen getting into a car in Bandra with Indrani and Indrani’s driver, Shyamvar Rai. After that: nothing. Rahul reported her missing; the police weren’t interested. Indrani said Sheena had moved to the US. A text from Sheena’s phone told Rahul to stop looking for her.

A month later, villagers in Raigad district found a burnt, decomposing body in a forest near Pen. Local police recorded it, took no action, and the file sat for three years.

August 2015: the driver talks

In August 2015, Mumbai police picked up Shyamvar Rai on an unrelated arms charge. Under questioning, he said he’d helped Indrani and her ex-husband Sanjeev Khanna kill Sheena in the car, and that they’d driven the body to Raigad. Within days, Indrani and Khanna were arrested. Peter Mukerjea was arrested that November, accused of knowing about it and helping cover up; he has always denied that.

The case went to the CBI. The alleged motive was a tangle of money and anger: Sheena’s relationship with Rahul, disputes over property and Indrani’s finances, and Sheena allegedly threatening to expose the family secret.

The trial that won’t end

Charges were framed in 2017. The trial has been running ever since, with well over a hundred witnesses. Peter Mukerjea got bail in 2020. Indrani got bail from the Supreme Court in May 2022, after six and a half years in Byculla jail, and promptly wrote a memoir. Rai turned approver. Mikhail Bora, the brother, has testified that Indrani tried to have him killed on the same day; the defence says he’s unreliable.

And the central question of whether the Raigad body is even Sheena’s has been contested: the DNA evidence has been challenged repeatedly, and the defence has argued that Sheena is alive. As of this writing there’s no verdict.

Netflix’s take

The Indrani Mukerjea Story: Buried Truth (2024) is a four-part docuseries that gives Indrani a lot of airtime to tell her version. It’s compelling and frustrating in equal measure, because it’s built to leave you unsure, which is either honest or evasive depending on your mood. Watch it, then read the charge sheet reporting, and notice how differently the two feel.

What stays with me

It’s the three years. A body found in 2012, filed and forgotten, while the person who allegedly put it there went on hosting parties. We said the same about Koodathayi: the crime is one story, and the silence after it is the other.

Did you watch Buried Truth, and did it change your mind either way? Comments are open.

Podcast also available on PocketCasts, SoundCloud, Spotify, Google Podcasts, Apple Podcasts, and RSS.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Discover more from Lore in Noir

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading