Every year or two a headline says the Zodiac Killer has been identified. Every year or two it’s wrong. So here’s a clean separation of what’s known, what’s cracked, and what’s noise.

The confirmed crimes

Between December 1968 and October 1969, in the San Francisco Bay Area, a man killed five people and wounded two more in four attacks: a lovers’ lane in Benicia, a parking lot in Vallejo, a picnic spot at Lake Berryessa (where he wore a hood with the crossed-circle symbol), and a taxi in San Francisco. The cab driver, Paul Stine, was his last confirmed victim. He claimed up to 37 in his letters. Police have never substantiated more than the five.

The letters

That’s what made him. He wrote to newspapers, named himself Zodiac, included pieces of Stine’s shirt as proof, threatened school buses, and sent four ciphers. The letters stopped in 1974. The letters are also why he’s remembered and the Isdal Woman isn’t: he did his own PR.

The ciphers, honestly

  • Z408 was cracked in a week in 1969 by a schoolteacher couple. It’s a rant about collecting slaves for the afterlife, and it contains no name.
  • Z340 was cracked in December 2020 by three amateur codebreakers (an American, an Australian and a Belgian) after 51 years. It also contains no name. It’s mostly him saying he isn’t afraid of the gas chamber.
  • Z13 and Z32 are too short to solve conclusively. Z13 is the one that starts “My name is”; it will probably never be read with certainty.

So: two solved, neither identifies him. If anyone tells you a cipher names the killer, they’re selling something.

The suspects

  • Arthur Leigh Allen. The main police suspect, the subject of Robert Graysmith’s book and David Fincher’s film. Circumstantial evidence galore (a Zodiac watch, a military-style boot print, odd comments to friends). But his fingerprints and handwriting didn’t match, and a 2002 DNA test from a letter stamp excluded him, though that DNA may not be the killer’s. He died in 1992.
  • Gary Francis Poste. A 2021 “case solved” announcement by a group called the Case Breakers. Based on photo forehead scars and an anagram. The FBI said the case remains open. This is the one your uncle shared on Facebook.
  • Everyone else. Dozens of names, including a few put forward by their own children. None has been backed by police.

Why it’s unsolved

Four different police jurisdictions, 1969 forensics, a killer who stopped, and evidence that has degraded. The best remaining hope is genetic genealogy on the letter DNA, if there’s enough usable material, which is the same technique that cracked the Golden State Killer in 2018. People are working on it. Nobody’s succeeded.

For another case where the “solution” keeps getting announced and un-announced, read our Dyatlov Pass post.

Fincher’s Zodiac: masterpiece or three hours of men looking at paper? Fight me in the comments. (It’s a masterpiece.)

Podcast also available on PocketCasts, SoundCloud, Spotify, Google Podcasts, Apple Podcasts, and RSS.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Discover more from Lore in Noir

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading