Second stop in our “Girl” thriller tour. Last week it was Gone Girl; this week, the 2015 book that rode its coattails to twenty million copies and a Hindi remake. Does it earn the comparison?
The setup (spoiler-free)
Rachel takes the same commuter train into London every day, and every day it pauses at the same signal, where she can see into the back garden of a couple she’s named Jess and Jason. She’s built a whole fantasy life for them. She also drinks, a lot, and has blackouts, and still rides past the house she used to share with her ex-husband, who now lives there with his new wife and baby.
Then “Jess” (really Megan) goes missing, and Rachel was on that street that night, and she can’t remember what she saw.
What works
- Rachel. An alcoholic narrator whose memory is a crime scene in itself. Hawkins makes you feel the shame of the morning after, the bargaining, the gaps. It’s the most honest portrait of drinking in the genre.
- The voyeurism. The train window is a great device. We all do this.
- The three voices. Rachel, Megan and Anna (the new wife) take turns, and their timelines overlap in a way that pays off.
What doesn’t
- Every man in the book is some shade of awful, and by the end it feels less like a theme than a tell.
- The middle sags. There’s a lot of Rachel waking up, regretting, and taking the train again.
- Experienced readers will have the culprit by halfway. The book doesn’t quite have Flynn’s second gear.
Our take
A good thriller with a great narrator. It’s not Gone Girl; it’s not trying to be, despite the marketing. If Gone Girl is about performing a marriage, this is about being erased from one. Three and a half out of five empty gin-and-tonic tins.
Spoiler section
Tom, Rachel’s ex, is the killer, and the twist is that Rachel’s “drunken” memories of his violence were real all along; he’d been gaslighting her about her own blackouts for years. I like this more now than I did in 2015. The book’s real subject isn’t the murder, it’s how easy it is to convince a woman she’s unreliable when she drinks, and how everyone, including the reader, goes along with it.
Book or film?
Book. The 2016 film moved it to New York and cast Emily Blunt, who’s great, but it loses the London commuter texture. The 2021 Hindi version with Parineeti Chopra is worth a watch for curiosity, though it changes a lot.
Did you guess Tom early, or did Rachel’s unreliability throw you? Tell me below.
Leave a Reply