Every true crime blog eventually does a Ripper post. It’s the law. So let’s do ours properly: not another retelling of the murders (there are a thousand of those), but a ranking of the suspects, because that’s where the fun is.
Quick setup for the uninitiated: between August and November 1888, at least five women were murdered in Whitechapel, in London’s East End. Mary Ann Nichols, Annie Chapman, Elizabeth Stride, Catherine Eddowes and Mary Jane Kelly. The killer was never caught, the police files are thin, and the name came from a letter that was probably written by a journalist. That’s the whole foundation of a 138-year-old industry.
Tier 4: Please stop
- Prince Albert Victor. Queen Victoria’s grandson. He was in Scotland for at least one of the murders. This theory exists because “royal cover-up” is irresistible, not because of evidence.
- Lewis Carroll. Yes, the Alice in Wonderland man. Based on anagrams someone found in his books. Anagrams.
Tier 3: Fun, but no
- Walter Sickert. The painter. Crime novelist Patricia Cornwell spent millions trying to prove it, and her evidence amounts to “he painted dark things” and some letters that may not even be Ripper letters. Sickert was probably in France for part of autumn 1888.
- Francis Tumblety. An American quack doctor who was in London at the time and had a weird collection of anatomical specimens. The police did look at him. He fled to the US. Interesting, unproven.
Tier 2: The police’s own picks
- Montague Druitt. A barrister and teacher who drowned himself in the Thames in December 1888, right after the last canonical murder. Chief Constable Melville Macnaghten named him in an 1894 memo. The timing is the whole case, and there’s nothing else.
- Seweryn Kłosowski (George Chapman). A Polish barber-surgeon who lived in Whitechapel in 1888 and was later hanged for poisoning three wives. Inspector Abberline, who actually worked the case, reportedly liked him for it. The counter-argument: poisoners don’t usually switch to knives.
Tier 1: The one with a real case
- Aaron Kosminski. A Polish Jewish barber living in Whitechapel, later committed to an asylum. He’s named in the Macnaghten memo and in notes by another senior officer. In 2014, a shawl supposedly taken from Catherine Eddowes’ murder scene was DNA-tested and matched to Kosminski’s descendants. The problem: the shawl’s provenance is shaky, it had been handled by many people over a century, and the DNA work was criticised by other scientists. So he’s the best suspect we have, and the “proof” is still not proof.
Why it will never be solved
Because the evidence that would have solved it was never collected. No fingerprinting, no blood typing, no crime scene photography worth the name, and the one piece of physical evidence everyone points to has a chain of custody with more holes than Whitechapel’s streets. If you like your mysteries unsolved, this is the original.
We’ve got a soft spot for cases where the clue is a torn scrap of something: see the Somerton Man if you haven’t.
Who’s your Ripper? Argue with me in the comments. I’m Team Kosminski with a big asterisk.
Leave a Reply